Whiskey, brandy, and cognac each offer distinct experiences for South African spirits lovers. Whether you're pouring at home or ordering at a pub, knowing the difference adds confidence to your sip. How to tell them apart begins with understanding what they’re made from, how they’re aged, and where they come from.
What’s the Difference?
The key difference lies in the ingredients and distillation methods. Brandy is distilled from fermented fruit juice—mostly grapes—while whisky is made from grain mash, such as barley, rye, or corn. Cognac, a type of brandy, must come from the Cognac region of France and follow strict production standards.
How to tell them apart by taste? Brandy typically has a warm, fruity sweetness with notes of dried apricot, vanilla, and spice. Whisky offers a broad range—from the honeyed smoothness of a single grain to the smoky, peaty bite of an Islay-style dram. Cognac is refined and floral, with layers of oak, fig, spice, and a soft, velvety finish.
Photo by Tim Durand/Pexels
Age and Maturity
Age impacts flavour depth significantly. Whisky aged in oak barrels develops bolder profiles—smoke, dark chocolate, toasted nuts, or sea salt, depending on the cask. Brandy ages into a mellow, rich character with dark fruit, caramel, and nutty notes. Cognac, graded VS (2+ years), VSOP (4+), or XO (10+), matures into a silky texture with flavours of orange zest, cinnamon, honey, and sometimes leather or tobacco.
South African Spirits to Try
South Africa excels in brandy, with producers like KWV, Van Ryn’s, and Oude Meester leading the pack. Van Ryn’s 15-Year-Old bursts with butterscotch, spice, and plum, while KWV 10-Year offers toasted oak and ripe stone fruit. Whisky fans should try Bain’s Cape Mountain Whisky, known for its vanilla, banana, and toffee creaminess. Three Ships 10-Year Single Malt delivers peat smoke, black pepper, and malt richness—perfect for lovers of bold drams. While cognac must be imported, labels like Rémy Martin XO or Camus Borderies are favourites among South African connoisseurs.
The Final Sip
How to tell brandy from whisky—or distinguish cognac from both—comes down to understanding their unique characters. Brandy comforts with soft, fruity warmth. Whisky excites with smoky depth or grainy complexity. Cognac seduces with its balance and refinement. Whether you’re sipping a spicy Three Ships, a plush Van Ryn’s, or a fine French cognac, every pour tells a story worth tasting. So raise your glass—and let your palate lead the way.
